Validated payment plans through A/B testing as a lever to improve claim recovery rate and reduce insurance losses.
When a renter moves out and a claim is approved, Jetty pays the property manager upfront — then seeks repayment from the renter. This recovery moment is critical: every dollar we don’t recover is a direct loss.
As an insurance business, profitability is measured by loss ratio — the ratio of claims paid to premium earned. By Q3 2023, our loss ratio had climbed to 108%, meaning we were paying out $108 in claims for every $100 in revenue.
Improving our claims recovery rate became one of the most direct levers we had to bring this ratio back in check.
Despite high engagement with our repayment features, claim payment conversion lagged — particularly for renters with larger balances. User research revealed the core issue wasn’t intent, but affordability.
We hypothesized affordability — not awareness — was the primary barrier for renters with high claim balances. To test this, we ran a painted door A/B experiment:
We defined success across 3 dimensions:
The tests validate our hypothesis as the results were strong:
The test validated our hypothesis and gave us the confidence to invest in a self-serve payment plan experience, projected to recover an additional $1.8M annually.